Skip to main content
HHMI BioInteractive
  • Español
  • Site Search
  • Log In/Create Account
  • Classroom Resources
  • Teaching Tools
  • Professional Development
  • Partner Content

The Origin of Flight: What Use Is Half a Wing?

Topic

  • Anatomy & Physiology
  • Skin & Musculoskeletal System
  • Evolution
  • Paleobiology
  • Scientific Skills & Literacy
  • Experimental Design

Resource Type

  • Videos
  • Scientists at Work

Level

High School — GeneralHigh School — AP/IBCollege

Duration

00:08:16
Saved By
11 Users
Share This

Description

In this video, biologist Ken Dial demonstrates that birds use their wings for more than just flying, which may help us understand how dinosaurs used their small wing-like limbs before the evolution of flight.

Critics of evolutionary theory asked Charles Darwin “What use is half a wing?” In other words, what evolutionary advantage would a feathered limb, the precursor to a wing, provide? Dial’s research suggests an answer. At the University of Montana’s Flight Lab, he has been researching the mechanics of bird flight and wing use. His experiments with young birds that have wings but still can’t fly provide a plausible hypothesis for the use of feathered limbs by flightless dinosaurs.

The video provides a clear example of the scientific process in action, and how the behaviors of modern species can provide insight into the behaviors of species known only from the fossil record.

The accompanying “Student Worksheet” incorporates concepts and information from the video.

An audio descriptive version of the film is available via our media player.

Student Learning Targets

  • Learn about research practices.
  • Develop scientific explanations and justify claims using evidence.
  • Analyze and interpret data from a scientific experiment.

Estimated Time

One 50-minute class period to complete the associated handouts.

Key Terms

adaptation, bird, co-option, dinosaur, exaptation, scientific methodology, scientific process, theropod

Terms of Use

Please see the Terms of Use for information on how this resource can be used.

Accessibility Level (WCAG compliance)

PDF files meet criteria. Video files meet criteria.

Version History

Date Published 11.09.15
Date Updated 10.19.17

NGSS (2013)

HS-LS4-4; HS-LS4.C; SEP4, SEP5

AP Biology (2019)

EVO-1.D; SP6

IB Biology (2016)

5.1, 5.2

Common Core (2010)

ELA.RST.9-12.7, ELA.WHST.9-12.1
Math.S-IC.3; MP3

Vision and Change (2009)

CC1; DP1, DP2

Materials

Download HD (M4V) 282 MB
Download HD (WMV) 248 MB
Download SD (M4V) 65 MB
Download SD (WMV) 67 MB
Download Transcript (PDF) 128 KB
Download Student Worksheet (PDF) 716 KB

Use This Resource With

Interactive Media Resource
Interactive Video Builder

Explore Related Content

Other Resources About Birds

Showing of
Photo of a hawk from the video
Film Activities
Activity for The Origin of Birds
Photo of a bird fossil from the activity
Lessons
Living Dinosaurs: Fact or Fiction?
Graph from the activity
Data Points
Effects of Natural Selection on Finch Beak Size
Image of a chicken skeleton from the interactive
Click & Learn
Comparative Anatomy of the Domestic Chicken
Image of a bird from the film
Short Films
Great Transitions: The Origin of Birds
Image from the activity
Data Points
Thermoregulation in Dinosaurs
Image from the interactive showing outlines of two elephants.
Click & Learn
How Animals Use Sound to Communicate
Photo of a finch
Short Films
The Origin of Species: The Beak of the Finch
Montage of finch pictures from the interactive
Click & Learn
Sorting Finch Species
Image from the activity
Lessons
Evolution in Action: Data Analysis
Photo of a finch's head and beak
Labs & Demos
Beaks As Tools: Selective Advantage in Changing Environments
Screen shot of the quiz
Interactive Videos
Interactive Assessment for The Beak of the Finch
Screen shot of quiz screen
Interactive Videos
Interactive Assessment for The Origin of Birds
Photo of a finch
Card Activities
How Can We Explain Evolutionary Relationships among Species?
Image of a beak of a finch
Film Activities
Activity for The Beak of the Finch
A montage of images from the activity
Lessons
How Did Dinosaurs Regulate Their Body Temperatures?

Other Related Resources

Showing of
Photo of a hawk from the video
Film Activities
Activity for The Origin of Birds
Image of a bird from the film
Short Films
Great Transitions: The Origin of Birds
Screen shot of quiz screen
Interactive Videos
Interactive Assessment for The Origin of Birds
Photo of Neil Shubin holding Tiktaalik fossil
Feature Films
Your Inner Fish
Computer illustration of a mammal precursor
Feature Films
Your Inner Reptile
Photo of Neil Shubin with a monkey on his shoulder
Feature Films
Your Inner Monkey
Computer image of Tiktaalik from the video
Film Activities
Activity for Your Inner Fish
Image of a chicken skeleton from the interactive
Click & Learn
Comparative Anatomy of the Domestic Chicken
Image of the 3D skull from the interactive
3D Models
Tiktaalik Fossil: Skull
Image of the 3D body from the interactive
3D Models
Tiktaalik Fossil: Body
HHMI BioInteractive
  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Our Advisors
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Newsletter Signup
  • HHMI.org
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility